La diffusion audio des décisions des arbitres assistants vidéo est un “petit pas en avant” pour clarifier les incidents, a déclaré le chef des arbitres, Howard Webb.
L’application de la technologie VAR a été remise en question et critiquée par les managers, les joueurs et les experts tout au long de la saison de Premier League.
Dans le but d’améliorer la transparence, Webb est apparu sur Sky Sports pour expliquer comment les décisions clés ont été prises, aux côtés des experts Jamie Carragher et Gary Neville.
“Nous cherchons à le faire [release audio] autant que possible”, a déclaré Webb dans Monday Night Football.
“Ce soir, c’est évidemment quelque chose de nouveau. Nous faisons un petit pas en avant. À l’approche de la saison prochaine, nous chercherons à faire plus de la même chose.
“Nous ne pouvons pas le jouer en direct, la Fifa ne nous autorise pas à le jouer pendant le match – qui sait où cela pourrait aller à l’avenir – mais rien ne nous empêche de montrer cette information plus tard.”
L’audio du jeu a été publié par Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL) à partir de six matchs cette saison, les supporters pouvant entendre les discussions avant que Webb n’offre de plus amples informations.
Newcastle 0-2 Arsenal – VAR annule la décision de sanction (7 mai)
Ce qui s’est passé?
L’arbitre Chris Kavanagh a accordé à Newcastle un penalty pour le handball lorsque le tir de Bruno Guimaraes a frappé Jakub Kiwior, mais le VAR Michael Salisbury a annulé la décision avec des rediffusions montrant que le ballon avait d’abord touché la cuisse du défenseur avant tout contact avec son bras.
Quelle a été la réaction à l’époque ?
S’exprimant sur BBC Radio 5 Live, l’ancien défenseur de Liverpool, Stephen Warnock, a déclaré: “C’est parti de la cuisse puis du bras, ce n’est certainement pas un penalty. Je ne sais pas pourquoi les fans de Newcastle sont si furieux.”
VAR Salisbury : “Nous allons vérifier la pénalité pour vous… pouvez-vous confirmer que c’est bien le bras et qu’il n’a pas touché la cuisse en premier ? Nous devons confirmer que ce n’est pas sa cuisse.
“On dirait que c’est de la cuisse au bras. Donc le bras est, pour moi, dans une position naturelle. Le ballon sort de la cuisse et fait un mouvement dans ce bras. Je ne crois pas que ce ne soit pas un penalty.
“Je vais recommander un examen sur le terrain du penalty que vous avez accordé. Ce que nous vous montrons, c’est l’impact du ballon et la position du bras.”
Arbitre sur le terrain Kavanagh: “Donc, nous avons d’abord une déviation du genou. Montrez-moi une fois de plus. Le bras est proche, ma première réaction a été que le bras était sorti, donc je vais recommencer avec un drop-ball au gardien de but .”
L’explication de Webb :
“Il y a deux choses sur celui-ci. Le ballon frappe clairement la cuisse – le short bouge – et le bras recule dans le corps et rend le joueur plus petit. Le bras n’est pas dans la position que l’arbitre pensait qu’il était.
“Je tiens vraiment à ce que notre utilisation du VAR soit cohérente. Celui-ci est un bon usage du VAR car il est différent de ce que l’arbitre a vu. Il y a encore des raisons pour que l’arbitre révise la décision sur celui-ci. .”
Chelsea 0-0 Liverpool – VAR renverse le but de Havertz (4 avril)
Ce qui s’est passé?
Kai Havertz avait un but exclu pour le handball après que VAR Kavanagh ait informé l’arbitre Anthony Taylor que le ballon était entré dans le bras de l’attaquant de Chelsea après que son tir initial ait rebondi sur le gardien Alisson.
S’exprimant sur BBC Radio 5 Live, l’ancien défenseur d’Arsenal, Matt Upson, a déclaré: “Vous pouvez voir sur la rediffusion qu’il tient juste son coude. C’est vraiment un bon arrêt d’Alisson parce qu’il reste grand et qu’il se détache du bras de Havertz et ricoche dans le net.”
VAR Kavanagh: “C’est factuel. Cadrez-le simplement sur le bras. D’accord, c’est clairement le bras. Je vous recommande de refuser le but. C’est du handball, mène immédiatement au ballon dans le filet. C’est factuel.”
L’explication de Webb :
“C’est une opportunité pour les officiels du VAR de voir quelque chose que l’arbitre sur le terrain n’a pas pu voir. Vous entendez Taylor dire qu’il pense que ça touche la poitrine, mais nous savons que si ça rentre dans le bras, ça doit être interdit.
“Dans cette situation, l’arbitre n’a pas besoin de voir l’écran car c’est factuel. Il n’y a pas besoin d’une autre interprétation.
“Plutôt que de perdre du temps en envoyant l’arbitre à l’écran, nous renversons la décision sur-le-champ et essayons d’être aussi efficaces que possible.”
Brentford 2-0 Bournemouth – VAR ne parvient pas à annuler le penalty (14 janvier)
Ce qui s’est passé? L’arbitre sur le terrain Jarred Gillett a accordé un penalty à Brentford en raison d’une faute de Marcos Senesi sur Ivan Toney, un appel qui a été soutenu par VAR Marriner, bien que Toney semble tenir le bras du défenseur avant que la faute ne se produise.
Quelle a été la réaction à l’époque ? Le manager de Bournemouth, Gary O’Neil, a qualifié la décision d’accorder le penalty de “scandaleuse”, ajoutant: “Je ne sais pas comment vous vous trompez avec VAR.” Mais, s’exprimant sur BBC Radio 5 Live, l’ancien défenseur du Pays de Galles James Collins a déclaré que c’était “une pénalité claire et” très maladroite “.
De quoi a-t-il été question ?
Arbitre Gillett: “Le deuxième. Tenir avec le bras autour de lui et le tirer vers le bas.”
VAR Marriner : “Il y en a assez pour soutenir cela. Vérification terminée.”
L’explication de Webb :
“Je ne pense pas qu’il y ait quoi que ce soit qui suggère que ce soit une erreur évidente, mais évidemment nous ne vérifions pas seulement l’action finale mais aussi la phase qui mène à cette décision.
“Dans cette situation, nous voyons une faute de Toney sur Senesi, avant que Senesi ne mette son bras sur Toney. La séquence n’a pas commencé assez tôt. C’est une question de processus plutôt que de jugement. Toney se verrouille et emprisonne son bras et cela devrait être pénalisé d’un coup franc pour Bournemouth.
“Nous savons que de longues vérifications peuvent causer de la frustration, mais nous espérons qu’en diffusant ces audios, vous pourrez voir qu’il y a un processus.
“Nous ne pouvons pas sacrifier la précision pour la vitesse. Dans ce cas, VAR n’a pas analysé en profondeur la séquence complète qui a conduit à ce contact entre Toney et Senesi. Si c’était le cas, cela aurait montré l’action de Toney et conduit à la pénalité être renversé. »
Engels made more than 50 appearances in the Bundesliga and made his Belgium debut as a substitute in Friday’s 3-1 win over Israel – two days before his birthday.
However, he believes that playing for Celtic will help him progress further and that “it’s an amazing team” and “everybody is teaching me a lot” already.
“It’s a really big club,” he said. “I think it’s the biggest club in Scotland – they play every time for the championship and for the cups.
“So it’s obvious that it’s a step forward for me and also, with the new format of the Champions League, I think it can be really amazing and special.
“To be under pressure to win every game – this is something I want to experience.”
Engels moved to Germany 18 months ago, having come through Club Bruges’ youth academy.
“I left home really early and I needed to do things for my own and look after myself,” he said.
“It helped me to grow up really quickly – actually quicker than I expected. I always believed in myself and that’s why I made the step there and that’s why I also made the step here, because I believe in myself and I want to show what I have got.”
Engels played for Bruges’ B team while current Rangers manager Philippe Clement was in charge and the pair greeted each other at Celtic Park before he made his debut as a substitute in his side’s 2-0 derby victory.
“I worked with him, so it’s normal that we see each other,” Engels said before adding that, although “it was nice to see him”, it was also good “to beat him”.
Republic of Ireland Under-21s’ hopes of qualifying for the 2025 Euro finals suffered a blow as they were held to a 2-2 draw at Tallaght Stadium by a Latvia team who had previously failed to pick up any points away from home during their campaign.
The Irish took the lead on 16 minutes when Rocco Vata pounced on a wayward Latvia pass and played the ball through to Sinclair Armstrong, whose initial shot was well saved by Janis Beks, but the ball fell to him kindly and he coolly passed into the net.
The hosts were well in control and Armstrong forced the visiting keeper into a fine save, while Vata scuffed a shot wide and then crashed a shot from distance off the inside of the post.
Three minutes before the interval Latvia levelled when Adolfs Maslovs ran down the right and crossed for Kaspars Anmanis to meet the ball first time and fire past Josh Keeley.
A blundered attempted catch by Keeley in the 63rd minute left Ivans Patrikejevs to score with a simple header but two minutes later Sean Roughan equalised with a drilled finish after an excellent ball from Andy Moran.
With only one automatic qualification spot up for grabs, Jim Crawford’s side trail group leaders Italy by four points with a match in hand, with Norway two points behind the Irish in the battle for second place.
The Monday Night Club’s Chris Sutton and Rory Smith look at how 39-year-old Cristiano Ronaldo is “holding Portugal back” despite scoring in back-to-back Nations League games.
WATCH MORE: Ronaldo inspires me to play for as long as possible – Kane
READ MORE: Ronaldo goals prove Saudi league quality – Neves
Listen to the best bits of the Monday Night Club in the Football Daily podcast.
“We’re used to that. We love to feel hard done-by. But this, legitimately, is arguably one of the very favourable teams that they could have got.”
Glasgow City have twice reached the quarter-finals, the latest in 2020, but no Scottish side has reached the 16-team group stage since it was established in the 2021-22 season.
Celtic were unseeded in the “champions path” section of Monday’s draw after winning their qualifying mini-tournament for the first time in three attempts.
Meanwhile, three top-20 clubs are guaranteed to miss out from the five “league path” ties.
Corsie pointed out that former Scotland midfielder Kim Little’s Arsenal, who are ranked seventh and thumped Scottish Women’s Premier League runners-up Rangers 6-0 in qualifying last week, face a tough game against 12th-ranked Swedes Hacken, while fourth-ranked Paris Saint-German face Juventus in ninth.
Manchester City, who have Scotland goalkeeper Sandy MacIver in their squad, will be wary of Paris FC, despite the French side being ranked nine places below in 20th, given they knocked Arsenal out in qualifying last season.
“Three of those six clubs won’t progress,” Corsie said. “And then you have Celtic, who’ve got a huge opportunity.”
Corsie said you “can’t disrespect” the fact Vorskla are five-time champions of their domestic league but added: “I massively hope Celtic put in two huge performances and I think, if they do that, they will progress and that would honestly be fantastic for the Scottish game.”
If they do, they will be joining Sam Kerr’s Bayern Munich and fellow Scotland midfielder Erin Cuthbert’s Chelsea, who automatically qualified for the group stage as champions of their respective countries along with reigning champions Barcelona and last season’s runners-up, Lyon.
Meanwhile, Scotland midfielder Caroline Weir, who scored a double for Real Madrid last week on her return from a year out through injury, also has a great opportunity to be playing in the group stage.
Spain’s runners-up, who are ranked eighth in Europe, will be strong favourites to defeat 74th-ranked Sporting Lisbon, whose squad includes former Celtic forward Jacynta Galabadaarachchi.
Aston Villa have defended their Champions League ticket prices after a backlash from supporters, and insist they must make “difficult decisions” to stay competitive.
The club were labelled “out of touch” last week after revealing they were charging up to £97 a ticket for home Champions League matches this season.
Adult tickets for their four home matches in the new 36-team league format will be £85, £94 and £97, while season-ticket holders get discounted rates of £70, £79 and £82.
The Premier League club host Bayern Munich, Bologna, Juventus and Celtic in their return to Europe’s top club competition for the first time in 41 years.
Aston Villa Supporters’ Trust (AVST) criticised the move, but president of business operations Chris Heck has outlined why the club have charged so much.
He said: “We recognise and understand the depth of passion felt amongst fans and their recent frustration around ticket pricing. Achieving our sporting ambitions while complying with financial stability regulations requires difficult decisions.
“Financial fair play (FFP) rules prohibit owners from covering shortfalls to finance this ambition, so we need to generate as much revenue as possible through sponsorships, merchandise and ticket sales to ensure that we can keep the club where it rightfully belongs – competing and winning at the top of English and European football.
“Our priority will always be to match our collective ambition while ensuring that we are able to increase stadium capacity each season and provide the best matchday experience for all our fans.”
Republic of Ireland internationals Niamh Fahey and Leanne Kiernan have signed new contracts at Liverpool.
Fahey joined the Reds in 2018 and has captained the side since 2020.
Kiernan arrived in 2021 and has scored 19 times in 47 appearances for Matt Beard’s side.
Both players were part of the Liverpool team that won the Women’s Championship title in 2022 and then secured a fourth-place finish in the WSL last season.
“I’m absolutely delighted to have another season in red. I really enjoy my time here with the club and after a brilliant last season I’m looking forward to pushing on,” Fahey told Liverpool’s website.
While the 36-year-old remains focused on prolonging her playing career, the club confirmed that Fahey will “explore opportunities to gain coaching experience alongside manager Matt Beard and his staff” during the season.
“I’m preparing for a little bit of life after football,” Fahey continued.
“The offer to do some coaching – Beardy spoke with me and I’m so grateful for this opportunity to learn off everyone and get my ideas as well how things work off the pitch.”
Kiernan suffered a serious ankle injury in the opening game of the 2022-23 WSL season.
Former Premier League striker Nile Ranger has joined Southern League side Kettering Town.
The 33-year-old had been without a club since January 2023, last featuring as a substitute in Boreham Wood’s FA Cup loss to Everton 10 months earlier.
Prior to that he had two spells at Southend United, the first of which ended because of “reoccurring disciplinary issues”.
The former Newcastle academy graduate made his first appearance for Kettering during their 2-1 win against St Ives Town in the seventh tier on Monday.
“It was his first game, he hadn’t met the lads. He’s come in out of the cold, he’s not played for a while,” Kettering manager Richard Lavery told BBC Radio Northampton.
“You could see in the first half he was rusty, in the second half he turned up.
“There’s a lot more to come from him, he hasn’t played at those levels for nothing, has he?”
Ranger scored 25 goals in 147 appearances in the top four tiers of English football.
The Monday Night Club’s Rory Smith and Conor Coady look at why Lee Carsley is in pole position for the England manager role, while Chris Sutton thinks Eddie Howe should be given a chance.
WATCH MORE: England performance one of ‘proudest days of my career’ – Carsley
Listen to the best bits of the Monday Night Club in the Football Daily podcast.
Referee Chris Kavanagh was right to send Declan Rice off in Arsenal’s draw with Brighton, the Key Match Incidents panel has ruled.
The board – which reviews the big refereeing decisions in the Premier League each week – agreed the midfielder should have been dismissed.
Rice, who was already on a booking, nudged the ball away from Joel Veltman as he prepared to take a free-kick in the 49th minute of Arsenal’s 1-1 draw with Brighton last weekend.
It was the first red card of the England star’s career, with the panel agreeing his actions were “clear, deliberate and impactful” and a second yellow card was correct.
The panel, which unanimously backed the decision, wrote: “Rice knows what he’s doing – it’s a gentle touch, but once the referee sees it he has no choice.”
Arsenal were 1-0 up at the time after Kai Havertz’s goal, but Joao Pedro’s leveller earned Brighton a point at the Emirates.
The KMI panel is independent and made up of three former players or coaches, one Premier League representative and one from the Professional Game Match Officials Board, the referees’ body.
It also ruled the video assistant referee (VAR) was right to intervene in Trent Alexander-Arnold’s goal in Liverpool’s 3-0 win at Manchester United.
The goal was initially given but was then ruled out, with Mo Salah deemed to have been offside in the build-up.
It was the only on-pitch decision ruled to have been incorrect out of the 23 looked into for match week three.
The panel was unanimous in its support of every on-field call, except the decision not to give Crystal Palace’s Will Hughes a second yellow card in their 1-1 draw at Chelsea.
The midfielder, already on a booking, avoided a caution from referee Jarred Gillett despite pulling back Cole Palmer outside the box just after half-time.
The first caution was unanimously supported as correct, with the majority (3-2) supporting Gillett’s decision not to issue a second yellow.
However, two of the panellists argued: “Palmer is the wrong side of Hughes and has options left and right, therefore it is stopping a promising attack.”